About the song
“I Can’t Tell You Why,” a poignant ballad by the Eagles from their 1979 album *The Long Run*, stands out as a testament to the band’s versatility and emotional depth. Co-written by Timothy B. Schmit, Glenn Frey, and Don Henley, the song marked a significant milestone for the Eagles as it introduced Schmit on lead vocals, showcasing his soulful falsetto in a departure from their typical rock sound.
**Song Overview**
Recorded in March 1978, “I Can’t Tell You Why” was among the first songs completed for *The Long Run*. It resonates with a smooth R&B feel, influenced by Frey’s admiration for artists like Al Green. The track features Schmit’s lead vocals, infused with melancholy and vulnerability, complemented by harmonies from Frey and Henley. Frey’s melodic guitar solo adds a distinctive touch, blending seamlessly with Joe Walsh’s organ and Joe Vitale’s ARP string synthesizer.
**Background and Composition**
The song’s genesis stemmed from Schmit’s personal experiences, providing a heartfelt foundation for its lyrics and melody. Initially conceived with Schmit’s core ideas, Frey and Henley contributed to fleshing out the song during intensive late-night sessions. Schmit recalls the studio atmosphere as transformative, recognizing the song’s potential as a standout track for his debut lead vocal performance.
**Reception and Legacy**
Upon its release as a single in February 1980, “I Can’t Tell You Why” swiftly climbed the Billboard charts, peaking at number eight on the Hot 100 and reaching number three on the Adult Contemporary chart. Critics hailed Schmit’s vocals for their emotive quality, describing the song as a poignant love ballad with tastefully sparse instrumentation that enhances its haunting allure.
Over the years, “I Can’t Tell You Why” has endured as one of the Eagles’ most beloved tracks, earning accolades from music publications. Billboard ranked it number six on its list of the 15 greatest Eagles songs, underscoring its enduring popularity and critical acclaim. Rolling Stone also recognized its significance, placing it at number 11 on their list of the 40 greatest Eagles songs. Ultimate Classic Rock praised Schmit’s vocal delivery and Frey’s melodic guitar solo, solidifying its place among the band’s most underrated gems.
**Live Performances and Adaptations**
The Eagles included live versions of “I Can’t Tell You Why” on their albums *Eagles Live* (1980) and *Hell Freezes Over* (1994), showcasing its enduring appeal in their concert repertoire. Additionally, Schmit performed the song during his tenure with Ringo Starr & His All-Starr Band, further cementing its legacy in live performances.
In summary, “I Can’t Tell You Why” stands as a testament to the Eagles’ ability to craft emotionally resonant music that transcends genres. With Schmit’s soulful vocals leading the way, the song continues to captivate audiences, embodying the timeless allure of the band’s artistic legacy.
Video
Lyrics
Look at us, baby, up all night
Tearing our love apart
Aren’t we the same two people
Who lived through years in the dark?
Every time I try to walk away
Something makes me turn around and stay
And I can’t tell you why
When we get crazy, it just ain’t right
(Try to keep your head, little girl)
Girl, I get lonely too
You don’t have to worry, just hold on tight
(Don’t get caught in your little world)
‘Cause I love you
Nothing’s wrong as far as I can see
We make it harder than it has to be
And I can’t tell you why
No, baby, I can’t tell you why
I can’t tell you why
Every time I try to walk away
Something makes me turn around and stay
And I can’t tell you why
No, no baby, I can’t tell you why
I can’t tell you why
I can’t tell you why, no